Understanding the Difference Between Photography Lenses and Cinema Lenses

Photography and cinema, though both visual arts, require different tools to achieve their distinctive outputs. One significant area of divergence is the lenses used in each discipline. While both types of lenses serve the primary function of capturing light to create an image, they are designed with different priorities and features to cater to their respective uses. This article will explore the key differences between photography lenses and cinema lenses, shedding light on why professionals in each field opt for one over the other.

1. Construction and Build Quality

Photography Lenses: Photography lenses are typically more compact and lighter than cinema lenses. They are designed for portability, making them convenient for photographers who need to move quickly and change lenses frequently during shoots. The materials used are robust, but the emphasis is on keeping the lens light and manageable. The build quality is generally sufficient for regular handling but may not withstand the rigors of professional cinema production environments.

Cinema Lenses: Cinema lenses, on the other hand, are built like tanks. They are constructed to endure the demanding conditions of a film set, including frequent lens changes, heavy usage, and various environmental conditions. The robust construction often includes metal housings, smooth focus, and zoom rings with hard stops, ensuring durability and reliability over extended periods of use. These lenses are designed to maintain performance even under intense operational stress.

2. Focus and Aperture Control

Photography Lenses: In photography, the focus is often controlled automatically via autofocus (AF) systems. While manual focus is available, it is usually not as precise or smooth as in cinema lenses. The aperture control in photography lenses is also typically electronic, adjusted through the camera body. This setup allows for quick changes in aperture settings but can lack the smooth transitions needed in film production.

Cinema Lenses: Cinema lenses prioritize manual focus and aperture control. The focus rings on cinema lenses have a much longer throw (the distance the ring travels when rotated), allowing for precise and smooth focus adjustments. This precision is crucial for achieving the shallow depth of field and smooth rack focusing often required in filmmaking. Additionally, cinema lenses feature de-clicked (smooth) aperture rings, enabling seamless and gradual exposure adjustments without the noticeable jumps seen in photography lenses.

3. Optical Quality and Characteristics

Photography Lenses: Photography lenses are designed to produce sharp images with high resolution across a range of focal lengths. They often include aspherical elements, special coatings, and other optical innovations to reduce aberrations and enhance image quality. However, they may exhibit some breathing (a change in image size when focusing) and are generally optimized for still images rather than continuous motion.

Cinema Lenses: Optical quality in cinema lenses is paramount, with an emphasis on consistency and minimal breathing. Breathing can be distracting in video production, so cinema lenses are designed to minimize this effect. Additionally, cinema lenses often exhibit better color consistency across the range of lenses in a set, ensuring uniformity in the visual style of a film. The focus and aperture adjustments are smooth and precise, crucial for maintaining a professional cinematic look.

4. Cost and Accessibility

Photography Lenses: Photography lenses are generally more affordable and widely accessible than cinema lenses. The market for photography gear is much larger, driving competition and innovation while keeping prices relatively lower. This accessibility makes them ideal for enthusiasts and professionals who do not require the specialized features of cinema lenses.

Cinema Lenses: Cinema lenses are a significant investment. Their superior build quality, precise controls, and optical performance come at a premium. They are typically used by professional filmmakers and production studios where the budget allows for such specialized equipment. The higher cost is justified by the demands of high-end film production, where any compromise in quality can be noticeable.

5. Mounting and Compatibility

Photography Lenses: Photography lenses are designed to be used with specific camera systems, and each manufacturer has its proprietary mount. Adapters are available, but they can sometimes compromise functionality and performance.

Cinema Lenses: Cinema lenses are often designed with a variety of mounts to be compatible with different cinema cameras. The PL mount (Positive Lock) is a common standard in the film industry, known for its secure and precise connection. This versatility allows filmmakers to use cinema lenses with various camera systems, enhancing their flexibility on set.

6. Consistency of Filter Threads and Lens Characteristics

Photography Lenses: In the realm of photography, filter thread sizes can vary significantly from one lens to another, even within the same brand. This variation necessitates photographers to carry multiple filters or step-up/step-down rings to adapt filters to different lenses. While not a major issue for photographers capturing still images, it can be inconvenient and time-consuming, especially during fast-paced shoots where changing lenses and filters frequently is required.

Cinema Lenses: Cinema lenses, particularly those designed as part of a set, often feature consistent filter thread sizes and other standardized characteristics. This uniformity allows for quick and efficient changes between lenses without the need for adjusting or swapping out filters and other accessories. Additionally, cinema lenses within a set are designed to have consistent color reproduction, contrast, and sharpness, ensuring that footage from different lenses matches seamlessly. This consistency is critical in maintaining a uniform visual style and reduces the need for extensive color grading in post-production.

7. T-Stops vs. F-Stops

F-Stops: F-stops (or f/numbers) measure the aperture size of a lens, which controls the amount of light entering the camera. The f-stop value is calculated by dividing the focal length of the lens by the diameter of the aperture. For example, an f/2.8 aperture on a 50mm lens means the aperture diameter is approximately 17.86mm (50 ÷ 2.8). F-stops are widely used in photography because they are easy to calculate and understand, and they provide a good approximation of the light transmission through the lens.

T-Stops: T-stops (or transmission stops) measure the actual amount of light that passes through the lens and reaches the sensor. Unlike f-stops, which are theoretical values, T-stops take into account the light loss due to the lens elements' absorption and reflection. Therefore, T-stops provide a more accurate measurement of the effective exposure. This precision is crucial in filmmaking, where consistent exposure across different lenses is necessary for maintaining visual continuity. Cinema lenses are typically rated in T-stops to ensure that when a lens is set to T2.8, it will transmit the same amount of light as any other lens set to T2.8, regardless of their design or construction.

Conclusion

While both photography and cinema lenses aim to capture the best possible image, their design, construction, and features reflect the distinct needs of photographers and filmmakers. Photography lenses prioritize portability, affordability, and quick operation, making them ideal for capturing still images. In contrast, cinema lenses focus on durability, precise manual control, minimal optical breathing, consistent quality, and accurate light transmission, catering to the demanding nature of professional filmmaking. Understanding these differences helps professionals in both fields choose the right tools to achieve their creative vision.

Watch the full video here